Gas Runs 50 Cents Cheaper in Evanston Than Garden City

Regular was $3.899 cash at an Evanston Chevron and $4.399 in Garden City this week. Wyoming's lower fuel tax and in-state refineries help, but taxes explain only part of the gap.

Share
Gas Runs 50 Cents Cheaper in Evanston Than Garden City
Evanston, Wyo.: Chevron near Depot Square, regular $3.899 cash, $4.099 credit, diesel $6.129. Photo by Darren Eastman, about Nov. 14, 2026.

Driving between Bear Lake and Evanston this week? Fill up on the Wyoming side. Pump prices photographed by Darren Eastman around Nov. 14 show regular gasoline 50 cents a gallon cheaper in Evanston than in Garden City, and diesel 57 cents cheaper.

Evanston, Wyoming

At the Chevron by Evanston's Depot Square, regular was $3.899 a gallon cash ($4.099 credit/debit), and diesel was $6.129. That's in line with the Wyoming average: AAA put the statewide average at $3.955 for regular and $6.064 for diesel on Nov. 14.

Garden City, Utah

Garden City, Utah: Chevron near the Bear Lake State Park Marina turnoff, regular $4.399, ethanol-free $5.799, diesel $6.699. Photo by Darren Eastman, about Nov. 14, 2026.

At the Chevron a quarter mile from the Bear Lake State Park Marina, regular was $4.399 cash, ethanol-free regular was $5.799, and diesel was $6.699. That's about 28 cents above AAA's Utah average of $4.122 for regular on Nov. 14 ($6.137 for diesel), so Garden City is pricier than the rest of the state, too.

Why Wyoming runs cheaper

Taxes are part of it. Wyoming's gas tax is 24 cents a gallon. Utah's is 31.9 cents through Dec. 31 under a temporary cut from 37.9 cents that took effect July 1, according to Utah code. On diesel, Utah's 37.9 cents compares with Wyoming's 24 cents. That covers roughly 8 cents of the 50-cent gap on regular and about 14 cents of the diesel gap. The rest comes down to local market conditions.

Wyoming also refines its own fuel. The U.S. Energy Information Administration counts four operating refineries in the state, with 127,000 barrels a day of crude capacity. They include HF Sinclair's 94,000-barrel-a-day Parco refinery in Sinclair and its 30,000-barrel-a-day Casper refinery, which mostly runs Wyoming and Rocky Mountain crude, plus Par Pacific's 20,000-barrel-a-day Wyoming Refining Co. in Newcastle. HF Sinclair's old Cheyenne refinery now makes renewable diesel.

Prices are dropping almost everywhere. AAA says the national average fell below $4 this week for the first time since July and was $3.84 on Nov. 14, as crude prices fall and stations switch to cheaper winter-blend gas. But AAA also says this is still the most expensive November on record.

Sources: Pump photos by Darren Eastman (Evanston and Garden City Chevron stations, about Nov. 14, 2026); AAA state gas price averages (Nov. 14, 2026) and AAA news release (Nov. 12, 2026); Utah Code 59-13-201; Tax Foundation 2026 state gas tax data; DMA fuel tax rates (Oct. 1, 2026); U.S. EIA Wyoming refinery capacity; HF Sinclair and Par Pacific facility pages.